Two Sister Buildings: America Demolishes the Cyclorama, Pakistan Saves the Embassy

Cyclorama Demolition Feb 28 2013

Photo courtesy of Matthew Amster.

After a well-executed legal battle of 13 years, including a 1998 determination by the National Register of Historic Places of its “exceptional historic and architectural significance,” the Gettysburg Memorial known as the Cyclorama has been demolished by the National Park Service. Dedicated November 19, 1962, demolition of the structure commenced February 18, 2013 with asbestos removal and was substantially destroyed ten days later.

Designed by the partnership of Richard J. Neutra and Robert E. Alexander the concrete, glass, stone, and steel Modern structure was considered a crown jewel of Mission 66, the famous mid-century program dedicated to improve federal parks through contemporary architecture commissioned by well-known architects. The Cyclorama was emblematic of postwar optimism and American confidence, a hallmark of the program.

The Cyclorama’s dramatic shape, a long rectangle terminating in a massive pure cylindrical drum mediated by flanking semi-circular arcs, resolved an equally compelling brief. The cylinder contained the 359-foot-long 26-foot high replica of an 1883 oil painting by French artist Paul Philippoteaux of Pickett’s doomed charge of Cemetery Ridge, which enveloped the viewer in a 360-degree circle.The desired unobstructed view required innovative engineering reminiscent of a circus tent, comprising a cable-suspe

The innovative "circus tent" engineering by Parker and Zehndorf. Photo from
The innovative “circus tent” engineering by Parker and Zehnder Associates. Photo from “Modern Steel Construction” January 1962.

nded roof of five 22-foot-long radiating steel trusses attached to a 3 ½-foot diameter, 18-foot tall cylindrical central pier. The engineering also facilitated a breathtaking connection to the site at the ground-floor auditorium. Here, sliding glass walls separated by “fins” clad in local stone, “Blue Mountain split-face Pennsylvania sandstone” engaged Cemetery Ridge and Ziegler’s Grove itself; the stone face, here at ground level below the smooth-troweled white concrete face of the cylinder, integrated structure and site. In a classic Neutra gesture melding interior and exterior, this north end opened to copses of trees and the battlefield, anticipating outdoor audiences gathered for speeches commemorating President’s Lincoln’s immortal address. The long rectangle to the south, with glass walls and vertical screen of metal louvers (intended to recall sober Classical facades) served administration. On the west it featured a ramp leading to a viewing station overlooking the battlefield. The majestic length of the ramp embodied the sense of somber procession memorializing a nation in crisis. Interior features of note included indirect lighting to enhance views of the site from many parts of the building.

Ironically, the engineering firm Parker and Zehnder, responsible for the Cyclorama’s “circus tent” truss system, also designed the engineering for another remarkable commission for Neutra and Alexander, the former U.S. Embassy in Karachi, Pakistan, completed virtually the same time in late 1961. Recalling the Cyclorama in its layout of strong concrete forms speaking to internal functions, its glass entry façade expressed a transparent democracy and American confidence, now abroad in the world. Its careful distribution of landscape elements included reflecting pools and ablution basins for Islamic employees that percolated throughout the compound, a gesture important to Neutra.

The former U.S. Embassy, looking east. Photo by Lucien Herve,

The former U.S. Embassy, looking east. Photo by Lucien Herve,

The Karachi structure also faced likely demolition after its decommissioning and potential sale. In contrast to the actions of the NPS, led by a group of concerned citizens and architects of the Institute of Architects, Pakistan (IAP), and encouraged by the U.S. State Department, especially Ambassador Robin Raphel, the government of Pakistan’s Heritage Committee declared it a national heritage on December 17, 2012. The former embassy will be rehabilitated and adaptively reused.

— Barbara Lamprecht
author, Richard Neutra – Complete Works

Advertisements
Comments
2 Responses to “Two Sister Buildings: America Demolishes the Cyclorama, Pakistan Saves the Embassy”
  1. studebiker says:

    I believe the Pickett’s Charge Cyclorama artwork housed in the old Cyclorama building was the original art that had been modified by others by removing the top 3 feet of sky. The Neutra team built the old Cyclorama building to the specifications given by the NPS and others were responsible for curating the art and designing and installing the hardware for its display.

    When the art was moved to the new exhibit facility it was restored to its original configuration.

    Thanks.

    Steve Stephen A. Montgomery 2115 1st Street Bakersfield CA 93304-2707 661-496-6585

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: